A substantive validity challenge involving the data center proposed by developer Brian O’Neill commenced on November 16th before the Plymouth Township Zoning Hearing Board. The property involved is 900 Conshohocken Road in Conshohocken (Plymouth Township), which was a steel plant for more than a century.
This type of challenge is a legal process in which a developer or property owner claims that the municipal zoning ordinance is arbitrary, unreasonable, exclusionary, or fails to have a significant connection to public health, safety, or welfare. In this case, O’Neill is arguing that the ordinance is De Jure Exclusionary (purposely meant to keep uses out), the Ordinance is De Facto Exclusionary (allows the use, but the regulations are such that it actually prevents it), and the ordinance fails to accommodate a
legitimate land use (data centers are a legal land use and can’t be banned under state law).
The opening of the hearing included announcements about the process and allowed people and entities to seek party status. No testimony was presented. Having party status allows a person or entity to present and cross-examine witnesses and appeal the hearing’s outcome.
Determining party status involves appearing before the zoning hearing board and requesting it by expressing a specific concern, not one that the general public could share. The applicant can question the person or representative of the entity and object or state that they have no objection. Prior to the start of the process, it was announced that every party to the special exception case (O’Neill is also seeking a special exception for the same proposed data center before the zoning hearing board) would receive party status in this case, and if a person or entity had been denied in the special exception case, the same would hold true for a validity challenge. New requests were considered.
Yes, we know this is getting confusing. Essentially, the proposed data center is following two separate paths towards approval. In the special exception case, O’Neill has to prove that a data center is of similar use to warehouses, laboratories, etc., which are approved uses in the Heavy Industrial Zoning District. In the validity challenge, he must show that the zoning code doesn’t give him a fair shot at approval.
In the end, 18 people and entities sought party status, and two were denied.
The most interesting aspect of the hearing involved those who didn’t seek party status but did receive it in the other process involving the special exception application. This includes the Borough of Conshohocken, the Conshohocken Sewer Authority, and Montgomery County.
The hearing was continued to December 21st.
Photo – Google