U.S. Department of Education investigating Colonial School District over policy that feds say allows district to hide gender transition from parents

The U.S. Department of Education announced on November 18th that the Colonial School District is one of five school districts nationwide that it is investigating “for policies that appear to conceal information from parents about a child’s ‘gender identity’ and actively facilitate ‘gender transitions’ behind parents’ backs.”

According to the federal department, Colonial and the other districts provide forms that ask minors to choose what names and pronouns they want to utilize in school, whether they want to receive counseling and “gender transition” support, and whether they want the school to keep their “gender identity” hidden from parents.

Within the announcement, it states that the department’s Privacy Policy Office “will determine whether the districts violated the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment, which requires schools to seek parental consent before asking students to fill out forms that reveal private information about themselves and their families, as well as the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, which requires schools to allow parents to inspect their child’s education records.  

Cited by the Department of Education is Colonial School District’s Policy 256, which was adopted on January 17, 2019. From the announcement:

Colonial School District, PA has a Board Policy 256, “Gender Expansive and Transgender Students,” that provides students the “right” to keep their gender status private and “does not require additional parental/guardian consent.” The District also maintains a confidential “Gender Support Plan” form to ask a student’s preferred name, pronouns, his or her “go-to” adult at school, and, whether or not parents should be included in their transition or informed. 

Within Policy 256, it states:

The goal in all cases is to strive for consensus between parents/guardians and student as to the application of this policy. However, in general, the prerogative to assert the rights of the transgender and gender expansive student belongs to the student and does not require additional parental/guardian consent unless the assertion of a right delineated in these guidelines implicates parental/guardian rights under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) or other applicable law.

The department goes on to assert that, in “order to circumvent parental involvement, several of the districts encourage maintaining ‘Gender Support Plans’ (or similar records) in separate filing systems” and that “District policies also allow school personnel to use a child’s legal birthname and sex when communicating with their parents but use the student’s ‘preferred name’ and ‘preferred pronouns’ when at school.”  

Colonial’s Policy 256 can be viewed here. In addition to the text of the policy, there are three available documents for download: the Gender Support Plan, Gender Transition Plan, and Preferred First Name Change for Student Records.

The nine members of the board at the time of adoption were Felix Raimondo (President), Leslie Finegold (Vice President), Mel Brodsky, Jennifer Dow, Eunice Franklin-Becker, Susan Moore, Rosemary Northcutt, Cathy Peduzzi, and Adam Schupack. None of those members are on the board today, and none have served in several years.

In addition to Colonial, the other four districts under investigation are Eau Claire Area School District in Wisconsin, Thompson School District in Colorado, Community Unit School District 300 in Illinois, and St. Paul Public Schools in Minnesota.

“The practice of schools withholding the most sensitive information about students from their own parents is unacceptable,” said Frank Miller, director of the student privacy policy office. “The law is clear: schools do not decide what information is shared with parents, the law does. Parents are the first-decision makers in their children’s lives and education, and SPPO will hold every educational institution accountable to ensure it upholds parental rights.”  

Violations of the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment can lead to enforcement actions and potential loss of federal funding. In recent years, the Colonial School District has received $1.42 million to $2.85 million annually (this does not include additional funding received in response to the pandemic).

In an article published by The Philadelphia Inquirer about this investigation, a district representative declined to comment on the investigation because it was a legal issue.

Photo – Raul_Mellado from Getty Images via Canva